This is the receptive, compliant, other-directed character whose life is a search for affection as a reward for being agreeable and cooperative rather than personally assertive. The contradiction is between low self-esteem (on grounds of being unlovable, unattractive) and a superficial optimism. A hopeful attitude helps dispel doubt and elicits encouragement from others. Passive-positive types help soften the harsh edges of politics. But their dependence and the fragility of their hopes and enjoyments make disappointment in politics likely. |
Why is someone who does little in politics and enjoys it less there at all? The answer lies in the passive-negative's character-rooted orientation toward doing dutiful service; this compensates for low self-esteem based on a sense of uselessness. Passive-negative types are in politics because they think they ought to be. They may be well adapted to certain nonpolitical roles, but they lack the experience and flexibility to perform effectively as political leaders. Their tendency is to withdraw, to escape from the conflict and uncertainty of politics by emphasizing vagues principles (especially prohibitions) and procedural arrangements. They become guardians of the right and proper way, above the sordid politicking of lesser men. |
|
Active Positive There is a congruence, a consistency, between much activity and the enjoyment of it, indicating relatively high self-esteem and relative success in relating to the environment. The man shows an orientation toward productiveness as a value and an ability to use his styles flexibly, adaptively, suiting the dance to the music. He sees himslef as developing over time toward relatively well defined personal goals--growing toward his image of himself as he might yet be. There is an emphasis on rational mastery, on using the brain to move the feet. This may get him into trouble; he may fail to take account of the irrational in politics. Not everyone he deals with sees things his way and he may find it hard to understand why. |
The contradiction here is between relatively intense effort and relatively low emotional reward for that effort. The activity has a compulsive quality, as if the man were trying to make up for something or to escape from anxiety into hard work. He seems ambitious, striving upward, power-seeking. His stance toward the environment is aggressive and he has a persistent problem in managing aggressive feelings. His self-image is vague and discontinuous. Life is a hard struggle to achieve and hold power, hampered by the condemnations of a perfectionist conscience. Active-negative types pour energy into the political system, but it is an energy distorted from within. |
Active-Negative Presidents and
the Presidential Power Equation
|
Barber: "I think Nixon was neither an accidental nightmare nor an automaton who rise and fall were inherent in "the system". He will be back, in his essentials, the next time the public elects an active-negative President....The American people had every opportunity to know what they were getting. They elected Nixon despite the most abundant evidence ever available regarding the character of any Presidential candidate". |
(Wilson, Johnson, Nixon)
the problem of self-esteem:
1) parents who demand perfection
2) children either are told they are or feel inadequate
3) have an all or nothing component to their actions
4) always trying to control their aggression
5) always have the temptation to fight or quit
6) often see the world in terms of conspiracy and/or chaos
7) feel they live in a dangerous world where you either fight or quit
they all RIGIDIFY
The process of rigidification:
1) they fight against giving in
2) they think that if they work harder things will change
3) they view themselves as alone
4) they appeal to faith
5) the identify an enemy
Richard Nixon as Archetypal Active-Negative
a great deal of work without much enjoyment
A man who has never lost himself in a cause bigger than himself has missed one of life's mountaintop experiences. Only in losing himself does he find himself. Only then does he discover all the latent strengths he never knew he had and which would otherwise have remained dormant". |
the grueling campaigner who succeeded by "slowing the pace" in 1968
life isn't about enjoyment, but about conquest
Nixon as self-manager
Nixon world view
Nixon style
Keys to Nixon:
childhood
college
![]() | Here is a quick look at the flow of events through Time magazine! |
Does his "character" come through? |
"President Harding had no ossification of the heart. He literally wore himself out in the endeavor to be friendly". |
| "Harding and Taft had in common the passive-positive's open, compliant and vulnerable character. They were different people in many other ways: Taft the juduicious exemplar of propriety, Harding the political playboy. But in character each reached out for love and sought to win it by being a winning personality. The passive-positive type lives in a marketplace of affection, trading bright hellos for smiles in return. What threatens the fragile structure of that adaptation is conflict and particularly conflict at close quarters...The passive-positive character is built around surfaces; when the surface begins to crack, collapse is imminent. Yet there is in this Presidential orientation a theme of great importance, resonating with strong popular needs. The loving uses of ppolitics are, compared with true love, superficial and fleeting. But for people in search of community, they provide a refreshing hopefulness and at least some sense of sharing and caring. That can be a motive for joining in politics, an emotional reason for staying in. The danger is its exaggeration: in a President-people romance that diverts popular attention from the hard realities of politics and twists the President's own thinking from his larger purposes to his dear friends". |
"dominated by the tide of reaction against too long and hard a time of troubles, too much worry, too much tension and anxiety....Reagan came on as a friend, a pal, a guy to reassure us that the story was going to come out all right" |
"fragile...having won in an election with the lowest turnout in 32 years". |
"dominated by rhetoric, with little interest in homework on the issues and little taste for the charms of personal negotiation...particularly if they involve an element of disagreement or confrontation. Further, his rhetoric is essentially ahistorical and apolitical . He is bound to contribute to the ever widening gap in American politics between speech and meaning". |
"despite various attributions of ideology, would be simpler than supposed: He is a Republican millionaire and hangs around with those folks...As long as Reagan's business friends are happy with moderation, he will be, too". |
"Passive-positive. That meant he would be definitely no Nixon--not a rigidified compulsive. Rather the danger was in his type's tendency to drift, particularly with forces in the close-up environment. The danger is confusion, delay, and then impulsiveness". |