History 356: Comparative
History of Women in the Third World
Class discussion for Aug. 28th
Reading: C.T. Mohanty, "Cartographies of Struggle" and Johnson-Odim
and Strobel, "Conceptualizing the History of Women in Africa, Asia..."
Terms, words and concepts to learn:
Third World
gender
monolithic
non-Western
agency
hegemonic
essentialism
patriarchy
Questions to consider:
Johnson-Odim and Strobel:
-
How do women (in any society) exercise power in ways that are not conceived
of as "power" or as powerful? How is power as a concept gendered?
-
How do certain institutions (concubinage, sex segregation) contain contradictions
for women? In other words, in what ways are institutions that are supposedly
"bad for women" advantageous to them?
-
Why do women participate in structures or institutions that subordinate
women? In other words, why do women participate in (seemingly) their own
subordination?
Mohanty: focus on her explanations from a point of view as
a so-called "third world" woman.
-
What are some of the issues that third world feminists have with western
women?
-
Why do third world women (or as Mohanty also says, women of color) question
the term feminism (p. 7)?
-
Why do third world feminists reject a "singular focus on gender as a basis
for equal rights"? (p. 12)
-
How does Mohanty define "third world woman"?
-
How does she link third world women's oppression as women to other
structures of oppression?
Overall:
What did you learn most from these articles?
What questions do you have that were unanswered from this reading?
Why do you think I assigned these particular articles?