History 356
Assignment: Paper #2
Due: Nov. 13, 2001

I. Purpose of the assignment: to gain insight into women's lives through either reading their own words and hearing their own "voice," or through reading a fictional account that deals with a woman or women's lives in a third world society. To analyze and evaluate the work as a source of history about third world women.

II. The assignment.

Write a 5-7 page essay on one of the books from the sign-up list. The paper should not "report" the story told by the author but rather, evaluate the work on its own merits. You will need to simply and succinctly summarize the main elements of the narrative but that should take no more than one page at the most. Questions and criteria for evaluating the book follow. You may raise other questions and issues to write about as well but the following need to be addressed in the paper.

1. Authorial intention. Who is the author and why do you think she wrote the book? She may be the author, a biographer, or a novelist. Whose voice does the author present? What is the "message" she is trying to impart, if there is a message? Is she trying to convince the reader of something, and if so, what is it?

2. The book as a historical document or source for history. How does the book enlighten the reader about the history of third world women? What are the major themes of the work, and how does the author deal with some of the themes we are focusing on in the course? What (if any) are some of the larger issues beyond the personal? How was the personal affected by the historical/political? Is the book able to provide the reader with historical information?

3. Memoirs, autobiography, biography, novels as sources of history. Evaluate this genre as a source of history: is it effective? What are its strengths, weaknesses? Take into account the genre. (Learn from the previous assignment! Remember that a novel is a work of the imagination.) NOTE: be very clear about this and what a book is. All books are NOT novels!

4. Quality and structure of the writing. Is the book engaging and well-written? Is it clear and well-organized? How well does the author approach her subject? How does the actual writing affect the reader's comprehension and understanding of the author's themes?

III. Style and Format
1. Audience and style:

Write this paper for an educated, well-informed reader (i.e., me) who knows something---more than the average person---about the topic. Do not write it for a general audience. Please avoid colloquialism, slang and the passive voice. This is a formal writing assignment but write in your own voice, and avoid trying to write in a style that is unnatural and complicated. Write clearly.

2. Format