| Paper Author | Reviewer |
|
|
|
| Cover Sheet | |
| Page Numbers |
|
|
|
| Spelling
|
|
| Grammar
|
|
| Punctuation
|
|
| Sentence Structure (in/complete)
|
|
|
|
| Paper maintains an academic tone
(no contractions, proper vocabulary, etc.)?
|
|
| Paper objectively written
(no "I feel" statements)?
|
|
| Paper written with active sentences
(avoids use of passive voice)?
|
|
|
|
| Introduction well-written? (Explain why)
|
|
| Thesis clear & concrete?
(Re-state in your own words)
|
|
| Introduction provides overview
of major divisions in paper?
|
|
| Paper organization logical? (Explain why)
|
|
| Conclusion summarizes main points
& provides closure to the paper?
|
|
|
|
| Paper thesis is well-supported by
details/facts? Examples?
|
|
| Each bit of factual information is clearly &
properly cited (or must readers guess its origins)? Examples?
|
|
| Paper contains an excessive/adequate
number of direct quotes?
|
Additional Comments: