Phl340 / hms 410 --W/00
Class #2 - T. Jan 11, 2000


 
Introduction to Course:  continued.

Last class:  explored possible meanings of "free will."  Saw two major alternatives:

  • Influences on choices do not determine the choices because there  is also the outcome of all those determining influences intersecting.
  • Influences on choices do determine the choices.  Any given choice is the outcome of all those determining influences intersecting.
This class:  discuss the three readings, using the questions handed out in class #1.

A.  Introduction.
   Discussion:  is the problem just learning to recognize what is 
   truly good so that we will seek it?  Education is the answer?

B.  "Always Time to Kill."  by Jason Epstein
   Discussion:  We humans show a terrifying eagerness under 
   some circumstances to become truly murderous.  List the
   main possible causes:  bad education?  testosterone? 
   resentment?  kin favoritism?  other...

C.  "Prisoner's Dilemman"  by Michael Berryhill [Cf. film, American History X]
   Discussion:  Does the social pattern in the prison--"checking,"
   gangs, etc.---reflect life on the outside as you have
   encountered it?  How could such patterns arise.  Who
   decided?  No one?  It is not the result of choices?  Why is the
   prison social pattern so similar from place to place then?

Summary question:  how much inner freedom is manifest in this human behavior?



For next class:  Dr. Monasterio's readings from Frankl and Sartre.
For next week:  select time for viewing movie
For later next week:  Readings on Ramayana and Bhagavad Gita.